| 2017 | William Edwards | 2009 | Anthony McComisky / Nicholas Mattera |
| 2016 | Nicholas Romanello / Brandon Wren | 2008 | Adthe Alajbegu / Michael McDermott |
| 2015 | John Albano | 2007 | John Blohm / Stephen Rivera / Len Chiarello |
| 2014 | Christopher Carbonaro / Joseph Frasca | 2006 | James Mandella / Craig Sikorski |
| 2013 | Nicholas Pucciarelli | 2005 | Frank Esposito |
| 2012 | Brett Bracco | 2004 | George Chicola |
| 2011 | Nicholas Gennaro / Peter Kennedy | 2003 | Stephen Hemmes |
| 2010 | Domenick Camerada / Nicholas Masica |
